Okay, I can’t resist. It’s list time again. (Lists rock.) I tend to gravitate toward the underdog, and that’s what the two following lists are about.
Back in 2010, readers responded to PWxyz’s request for the names of writers they thought were unjustly underrated. Here are Craig Morgan Teicher’s favorite fifteen from among their suggestions, listed in alphabetical order. (The complete list of 60 writers that PWxyz readers submitted follows the list of fifteen.)
He suggests that we “give these writers their due–go buy their books, talk ‘em up to your friends and enemies, and make them the literary titans they deserve to be!”
I myself am already a big fan of several of these writers.
Here are the top 15 Underrated Writers According to PWxyz (in alphabetical order)
- Donald Antrim
- Jo Ann Beard
- Anthony Doerr
- Deborah Eisenberg
- Stephen Elliott
- Steve Erickson
- Brian Evenson
- Percival Everett
- Mary Gaitskill
- Tessa Hadley
- Kelly Link
- Sam Lipsyte
- Lydia Millet
- Christine Schutt
- Matthew Sharpe
- Train Dreams by Denis Johnson
- The Pale King by David Foster Wallace

- Swamplandia! by Karen Russell
- The Call by Yannick Murphy
- State of Wonder by Ann Patchett
- The Marriage Plot by Jeffrey Eugenides
- The Devil All the Time by Donald Ray Pollock
- Changó’s Beads and Two-Tone Shoes by William Kennedy
- We the Animals by Justin Torres
- Open City by Teju Cole
- Someday This Will Be Funny by Lynne Tillman
- I Married You for Happiness by Lily Tuck
- The Art of Fielding by Chad Harbach
- The Buddha in the Attic by Julie Otsuka
- Ghost Lights by Lydia Millet
- A Moment in the Sun by John Sayles
- My New American Life by Francine Prose
- Stone Arabia by Dana Spiotta
- The Submission by Amy Waldman
- Ten Thousand Saints by Eleanor Henderson
- Rules of Civility by Amor Towles
- The Evolution of Bruno Littlemore by Benjamin Hale
- Salvage the Bones by Jesmyn Ward
- Once Upon a River by Bonnie Jo Campbell
- Binocular Vision by Edith Pearlman
- The Angel Esmeralda by Don DeLillo
- The Family Fang by Kevin Wilson
{via Publishers Weekly}
That’s why there are bloggers to let the world know! I will not have to read the others on the list that I haven’t read just so I can share them on my blog.
I’m obsessed with these four Jo Ann Beard, Deborah Eisenberg, Tessa Hadley, Kelly Link, and sad to know how underrated they are that they’re on the underrated list.
I, too, LOVE Deborah Eisenberg as well as Mary Gaitskill. I’m not certain what “rating” criteria were used, though. That would have been helpful to know. There are some amazing writers on this list, and it’s disheartening the world doesn’t know more about them.